Matching vs. Mixed Metals for Bathroom Remodels

Matching vs. Mixed Metals for Bathroom Remodels

9th Nov 2023

Many customers want their shower hardware to match the rest of the metal in the bathroom, while others are ready to try the more recent trend of mixing metals within one room. There are pros and cons to each style, so both are probably here to stay for the foreseeable future. Offering a wide range of metal finishes for your shower hardware ensures that clients will be able to achieve their design goals, whatever these may be. Let’s take a closer look at the thinking behind each of these two approaches.

 
 

Matched Metals: The Safe Option

No doubt about it, the more traditional choice is to coordinate the shower hardware, faucets, towels bars, accent items, and so forth within one bathroom. On the plus side:

  • Matched metals give the room a cohesive, intentional feel.
  • Using the same metal finish throughout the room is also simple. Instead of choosing contrasting and complementary finishes, a client only needs to pick one metallic finish that they like.
  • Shower hardware is generally available in a range of finishes so that it’s fairly easy to match existing fixtures.
  • Matched metals are such a classic that the look will never go out of style.
  • However, matching fixtures aren’t for everyone. Many of today’s décor modes favor a curated, collected over time vibe. Instead of ordering a matching living room set, decorators and designers are choosing an assortment of unique pieces, often from flea markets, thrift stores, or antique shops. From the viewpoint of these fashions, matching metals can seem boring or artificial.  
     

    Advantages of Mixed Bathroom Metals

    The points mentioned above lead some glass shower customers to choose shower hardware with a finish different from other metals in the space. A popular approach is to use a predominant finish, a secondary finish, and possibly a third accent finish. At times, this can relate to practical considerations. For example, matte black is very on-trend, but it’s inadvisable to use dark faucets in a bathroom with hard water because of the likelihood of permanent water spots. In a case like this, a customer might use polished nickel for all the shower, sink, and towel bar metal but include matte black by way of light fixtures, a metal framed mirror, and the soap dispenser. This method can give the room a layered look and the sense of a style that has organically evolved over the years. It can be helpful to picture what it would look like to introduce a new metal finish into your space, so click here to view some popular towel bar styles and their finish options.

     
     

    Disadvantages of Mixed Metals

    While many bathrooms are successfully adorned with mixed metals, there are possible pitfalls homeowners should consider before finalizing their shower hardware choices.

  • If done poorly, mixed metals can feel careless and disjointed.
  • Since matched metals are more popular, mixed metals may be riskier for resale appeal.
  • Although it’s been here for a while already, mixed metals could wane in popularity and be expensive to change out.
  • At the same time, there are steps a homeowner can take to reduce the risks. For starters, it’s advisable to do some research and draw on tips from professional designers. (We discuss some of these in the next section.) A little bit of reading can save an amateur from any significant faux pas. Another trick is to choose a very classic metal for the major fixtures and introduce a trendy metal by way of items that can be replaced more cheaply. If all the more permanent bathroom hardware is one finish, the fact that another metal has been introduced by way of a mirror frame, trash can, etc. should not be a turn-off to a prospective buyer.  
     

    Pro Tips from The Spruce

    The Spruce author Sarah Lyons provides tips from designers on how to successfully mix metals, whether through the shower hardware or other installations. Here are few highlights from the piece:

  • Avoid mixing similar metals, which can look like a failed attempt at matching, and instead choose contrasting finishes.
  • Within the one room, there should be at least two instances of each of the chosen metals.
  • Use just one finish on each individual item or fixture.
  • Think about the desired feel for the room as a whole when selecting the metallic finishes.
  • Whether your customer base prefers matched or mixed bathroom metals, you can count on Glass Simple. Our handles, hinges, clamps, and other shower hardware are available in a range of styles and finishes that your customers desire. Check out some of our hinges here, browse our site to see our complete offerings, and give us a call at (571)707-7760 to set up your B2B account and save 25% or more off listed prices!